top of page

Prepare for an adventure of culinary intrigue with our Rum Cake Surprise Flavor! Get ready to be pleasantly surprised by a gourmet treat that's not only delicious but also exhilarating. When you order this unique creation, we'll take the reins and handpick one of our delectable rum cakes to satisfy your cravings. It's a delightful journey into the unknown, where every bite is a delightful surprise waiting to be unveiled.


Don't let the opportunity for culinary excitement pass you by – order your Mystery Flavor Rum Cake today and embark on a thrilling adventure with your taste buds. Whether it's a surprise for yourself or a delightful gift for someone special, this delectable surprise flavor experience promises to add a dash of excitement to any occasion.



Non-GMO Pure Cane Sugar, Cake Flour, Canola Oil, Butter, Brown Sugar, Milk, Heavy Cream, Eggs, Rum, Corn, Syrup, Pure Vanilla, Baking Powder, Salt (made in a facility that processes wheat, peanuts, and other nuts)


Allergens: Wheat, Milk, Eggs, Dairy, Gluten


Instructions / Storage


How long do the cakes stay fresh?

With the exception of the Chocolate  Rum and the Malibu rum cakes, our cakes will remain fresh for 3 weeks in a cool location.

The Chocolate Rum and the Malibu Rum cakes should be refrigerated if not eaten within a few days.


Can the cakes be frozen?

Yes, the cakes may be frozen and thawed at room temperature.


How long will shipping take?

Our cakes are made fresh per order. We allow ourselves up to 72 hrs to bake them. We ship via UPS and the time frame is generally 1-3 days.

Special event orders, including birthday cakes, require at least one week advance notice. 

Express shipping is available at an extra cost calculated by UPS.


Here are three humorous and fun ways to prepare for the arrival of your Rum Cake Surprise Flavor:


1. The Blindfolded Taste Test:

   - Gather your friends or family and blindfold everyone.

   - When the cake arrives, have each person take a bite while still blindfolded.

   - Make it a guessing game by trying to identify the secret flavor. Hilarity ensues as taste buds and imaginations run wild with guesses.


2. Rum Cake Unboxing Extravaganza:

   - Treat the arrival of your rum cake like an extravagant unboxing event.

   - Set up a "cake reveal" table with a red carpet, confetti cannons, and dramatic music.

   - Capture the moment on video as you unbox and unveil the cake, building up anticipation and suspense.


3. The Blindfolded Cake Decorating Challenge:

   - Before the cake arrives, gather your friends and challenge them to a blindfolded cake decorating contest.

   - Provide an assortment of frosting, sprinkles, and toppings.

   - Once the cake arrives, have each participant decorate a slice of cake while blindfolded.

   - Compare the results for a hilarious and creative twist on cake decoration.


These funny and entertaining preparations will not only add a dose of humor to the experience but also make the arrival of your Rum Cake Surprise Flavor even more memorable and enjoyable.

Rum Cake Surprise Flavor

  • As our products are perishable, all food sales are final.

    Goodway Bakery will be happy to replace any item(s) in the unlikely event that they might be damaged or spoiled during transit. To make sure that you are satisfied with the product you receive, please inspect the contents as soon as your order arrives.

    Goodway Bakery is not responsible for damage or loss as a result of shipments being returned to the freight location or being undeliverable as a result of incorrect address information you supply to us, or for inability of a recipient to receive the package on the day you specify that it should be delivered.

    For more information, please contact our Customer Service department at 518.273.2091 8:30am - 4:30pm ET Monday - Friday.

  • Our items are baked fresh to order and shipped within 72 hours.

Related Product

Lorem ipsum odor amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit. Efficitur condimentum laoreet venenatis, maecenas faucibus quisque